Irish Enterprise Regulation Agency LLP Mason Hayes Curran

Kildare Meat Manufacturing facility Prosecution

Kildare Chilling Firm was fined €400,000 in respect of a office dying of an worker on 21 January 2022 at Naas Circuit Court docket. Alexandru Coceban died after he was struck by a forklift on the firm’s meat manufacturing unit.

Choose Mary O’Malley Costello stated Mr Coceban’s dying was “a most dreadful incident” which resulted from the corporate’s failure to supply a secure route for pedestrians on the manufacturing unit flooring of the Kildare plant. Choose O’Malley Costello remarked that it was laborious to see how the risks had been missed as there was an obligation on the corporate to make sure the security of its employees within the office.

Choose O’Malley Costello accepted proof that employees on the manufacturing unit had been cautious and that the corporate had a very good security report and engaged totally with the Well being and Security Authority in addition to not disregarding office threat on objective. She additionally acknowledged the regret proven by the corporate’s administrators and their response to the dying of Mr Coceban.

The court docket heard that the corporate engaged in common well being and security coaching for employees. The corporate carried out instruction in several languages and had made vital efforts to treatment its failings to make sure such a fatality doesn’t occur once more.

The Choose additionally praised the family-run agency for its assist for Mr Coceban’s household together with the funding of the repatriation of his physique to Moldova and its “appropriate and proportionate” response in coping with authorized claims.

No prosecution was introduced in opposition to any particular person mangers, administrators, or officers.

Prosecution of Dairy Processing Enterprise and Supervisor

Referring to a separate case, the Irish Farmers Journal reported that on 4 November 2021 at Ballinasloe District Court docket, Arrabawn Co-operative Society Restricted (Arrabawn) was convicted and fined €40,000 for breaching meals legislation. Arrabawn was ordered to discharge the Meals Security of Eire’s authorized prices and a contribution to the investigation prices.

A former high quality supervisor for the corporate was additionally convicted and fined €6,500.

The investigation discovered that paperwork had been illegally cast or altered and that these data had been then supplied to enterprise clients, third-party auditors and to authorised officers.

The breaches of meals legislation on this case included:

  • Two costs of possession of cast or altered paperwork regarding testing of pasteurised milk.
  • Possession of cast paperwork regarding testing and calibration data.
  • Possession of cast paperwork regarding packaging integrity and water remedy.
  • Failing to make sure that meals handlers had been adequately supervised and instructed and/or educated in meals hygiene issues.
  • Two costs of failing to adjust to microbiological standards for Enterobacteriaceae in pasteurised milk, and
  • Supplying inaccurate data regarding the folic acid content material of milk.

The Court docket famous in mitigation that senior administration at Arrabawn acted instantly in large-scale funding and improved governance preparations when discovering the breach.


These two circumstances point out that prosecuting authorities, and the Courts, will all the time be cognisant of the Supreme Court docket choice in DPP v TN in deciding whether or not particular person managers ought to be held to account for crimes dedicated by meals companies.

Accordingly, the particular person’s real-world operate and function is decisive, not their nominal job title. The particular person should, nonetheless, have actual authority and duty over the world in query to be thought-about doubtlessly criminally liable. A supervisor for this objective shouldn’t be confined to somebody in a top-level place. Satisfactory compliance coaching to all such managers liable to prosecution ought to be thought-about by meals companies.

For detailed recommendation on regulatory felony investigations and prosecutions please contact a member of our Well being & Prosecutions crew.

The content material of this text is supplied for data functions solely and doesn’t represent authorized or different recommendation.