I made 4 basic, comfort-food sandwiches in my air fryer, and there are 2 I will be making once more

  • Once you crave consolation meals, a heat sandwich is the proper choice.

  • I made grilled cheese, BLT, ham-and-cheese, and peanut butter-and-banana sandwiches in my air fryer.

  • The Cuban-style ham-and-cheese sandwich tasted prefer it was served up in a diner.

Air fryers in the reduction of time to realize comforting meals.

I attempted 4 basic sandwiches in my 3-quart PowerXL Vortex Air Fryer.Victoria Montalti/Insider

Consolation meals is, properly, comforting. It is often easy, heat, filling, nostalgic, and delicious. So when there is a option to lower down the cooking time to realize consolation, I am right here for it.

Air fryers can in the reduction of time on cooking and frying, so it is a fantastic choice for serving up scorching sandwiches. I personal a 3-quart PowerXL Vortex Air Fryer. I am comparatively new to making an attempt varied recipes in it, however thus far, dishes from rooster to do-it-yourself fries have been nice.

Insider’s Chelsea Davis additionally lately examined making sandwiches within the air fryer — and there are six she recommends — however I made a decision to see how among the classics would end up. So I made a grilled cheese, BLT, peanut butter and banana, and ham and cheese.

I used to be excited to make an 8-cheese grilled cheese sandwich.

Flat lay of sliced white bread, 4 cheeses, and a stick of butter.

Utilizing the cheeses I had out there, I mixed them with basic white bread.Victoria Montalti/Insider

For this grilled cheese, I did not use a selected recipe, and as an alternative went off the components I already had in my fridge.

I opted to make use of Sandwich-Mate’s American Singles slices and Cease & Store’s manufacturers of 4 Cheese Mexican Model Mix shredded cheese, sharp cheddar cheese, and Lorraine Swiss cheese (Swiss with smaller holes) from their deli.

In my view, white bread is perfect for a basic grilled cheese whether or not you are frying it in a pan or an air fryer.

I layered a number of cheeses on the bread, assembling it neatly within the air fryer.

6 images of the sandwich in the air fryer, each with an additional layer of cheese on it.

I layered American, Swiss, sharp cheddar, and Mexican-blend cheeses within the sandwich.Victoria Montalti/Insider

To start out, I preheated my air fryer for 3 minutes at 370 levels.

After buttering my bread and after the air fryer was preheated, I laid a bread slice buttered-side down within the air fryer and began to assemble it. I figured this is able to trigger much less of a multitude than if I attempted to maneuver the sandwich with piles of cheese on it.

I stacked a slice of American cheese, adopted by Swiss cheese, sharp cheddar cheese — which I shaved with a potato peeler beforehand — the shredded Mexican mix, and eventually yet one more slice of American.

Because of a tip from Heather in her Meals Lovin’ Household weblog’s grilled cheese recipe, I caught a toothpick in the course of my sandwich to maintain the air circulation from blowing off my high piece of bread. I adopted this tip in every of my 4 sandwiches.

After it was accomplished, I lower into the crisp bread and cheese oozed out.

Side by side of a grilled cheese cut in half and stacked on top of each other.

The bread was completely buttery and crispy, and the cheeses have been a pleasant gooey mixture.Victoria Montalti/Insider

I set the temperature to 370 levels and the timer for 4 minutes earlier than taking it out and flipping the sandwich for an additional 4 minutes.

From the oozing cheese spilling out once I lower it to the bites of crispy bread and mixture of tacky flavors, this sandwich stuffed me with a lot pleasure. Whereas a grilled cheese cooked historically in a pan is nice, the air fryer gave a extra even prepare dinner for my part, avoiding overly burnt bits that pans on the range can typically produce.

This was the proper comfort-food sandwich that I shall be coming again to make within the air fryer time and time once more.

Subsequent, I concocted a double-decker BLT.

Flat lay of bacon, lettuce, tomato, a loaf of bread, mayo, and a stick of butter.

The components for my air-fryer BLT.Victoria Montalti/Insider

A BLT is a basic and once you throw a 3rd slice of bread within the combine to make it a double-decker, it is even higher.

For this sandwich I used all the standard fixings of a BLT recipe however with low-sodium bacon and mayonnaise. I opted for a heavy bread, Nature’s Promise’s basic sourdough loaf, as really helpful in Laurie’s Fork to Spoon weblog’s BLT air-fryer recipe.

I’ve all the time needed to strive bacon within the air fryer so this appeared like the proper alternative. However my query was: Do I assemble the components on the bread earlier than cooking, or do I prepare dinner the components individually?

I sliced the bread and fried it with out butter on it.

Side by side of sliced bread stacked and three slices laid in the air fryer.

I sliced the sourdough bread and fried it within the air fryer to make the slices crisp.Victoria Montalti/Insider

It seems that some recipes counsel assembling all of the components and cooking them on the identical time within the air fryer, whereas others counsel heating up the bread and bacon individually earlier than assembling it with the chilly components. I opted for the latter.

I sliced the loaf of bread into three half-inch thick slices. I did not see any recipes counsel buttering the bread, so I did not. I preheated the air fryer to 370 levels earlier than inserting the bread in, ensuring the basket wasn’t too overcrowded.

I fried them for one minute on all sides. Visually, it did not make a distinction, however they have been extra crisp.

Subsequent I fried the bacon utilizing completely different ideas and methods.

Side by side of uncooked bacon and shriveled up fried bacon in the air fryer.

I lower the bacon to verify it did not overlap. It cooked properly however considerably shriveled up.Victoria Montalti/Insider

Then it was bacon time. Utilizing my very own judgment, I lower two slices of bacon into smaller items so they would not run up the perimeters of the basket or overlap.

Then I adopted Heloise Blause‘s ideas for air frying bacon, which she beforehand shared with Insider. I preheated the air fryer to 360 levels for 3 minutes. Then I positioned a slice of bread on the backside of the basket beneath the “fry plate” to absorb extra oil from the bacon and forestall smoking. This was genius and so useful for my part.

I positioned the bacon in and cooked it at 360 levels for six minutes earlier than checking it. After I did, I used to be in shock — the bacon had shriveled up a lot. I knew I wanted to make one other batch. Nevertheless, it was evenly crispy, simply the best way I prefer it, so I took them out then earlier than making my second batch.

I assembled the sandwich and whereas it seemed appetizing, it wasn’t my favourite of the sandwiches I attempted.

Side by side of bread gaining an extra ingredient next to the fully assembled double-decker sandwich.

I unfold mayo on the bread earlier than layering lettuce, tomato, and bacon with a slice of bread within the center.Victoria Montalti/Insider

For meeting, I first unfold mayonnaise and sprinkled black pepper on my three slices of air-fried bread (including mayo to either side of the middle slice to assist glue the components collectively). Then I began the enjoyable half: layering the components. Lettuce, tomato, bacon, bread, repeat.

Throughout my style take a look at, I got here to the conclusion that my creation was simply … alright. Sure, the bacon was excellent. However the whole lot else felt slightly lackluster. I felt that the bread was a bit mushy regardless of being air fried. I feel buttering the bread or, merely, simply toasting it will have been higher choices.

After making an attempt this, I would not essentially name it an air-fryer sandwich with simply two components fried in it. And whereas I do love a BLT, I do not assume this one lived as much as be a top-tier comfort-food sandwich.

Then I cooked a ham-and-cheese sandwich.

Flat lay of dark rye bread, sliced ham, sliced Swiss, a jar of pickles, mustard, and a stick of butter.

For my ham-and-cheese sandwich, I added pickles and yellow mustard.Victoria Montalti/Insider

Ham and cheese is a straightforward and comforting sandwich, and when the fillings are warmed up it is like a hug. However to separate it from my grilled cheese, I took some Cuban-sandwich influences to raise it.

For my Cuban-ish sandwich, I used marbled-rye bread, ham and Lorraine Swiss from Cease & Store’s deli, pickle spears, and yellow mustard. No, this isn’t a Cuban sandwich. However it’s a ham-and-cheese sandwich with some further tang that I used to be excited to strive.

I added layers of the fillings onto the bread.

Side by side images of the sandwich covered in mustard and gaining layers of ham, Swiss, and pickles.

I assembled the sandwich with mustard, ham, Swiss cheese, and pickles.Victoria Montalti/Insider

I buttered my slices of rye bread — the biggest slices I’ve tried within the air fryer — earlier than flipping them and spreading on yellow mustard.

My pickle spears have been too thick to function a sandwich filling, so I sliced them to be thinner.

Subsequent, I added two slices of ham, two slices of Swiss, the pickles, two extra slices of Swiss, and two extra slices of ham earlier than topping it with the opposite slice of bread. I positively ought to’ve put the cheese down first, moderately than the ham, so it might have served extra as a glue. As a substitute I added two toothpicks to maintain the sandwich collectively.

Since I had a meat filling, I borrowed from the BLT recipe and preheated the air fryer for 3 minutes at 370 levels. Then I fastidiously positioned my sandwich inside, simply becoming it within the basket, and cooked it for 4 minutes earlier than flipping it for an additional 4.

This Cuban-style ham-and-cheese sandwich was my favourite of the bunch.

Side by side of the sandwich with dark bread and the stringy cheese coming out of it.

This ham-and-cheese sandwich had crispy bread, gooey cheese, and crispy pickles.Victoria Montalti/Insider

Then it was time to eat. I lower the sandwich and, no, it was not the prettiest when in comparison with the BLT, but it surely was actually the tastiest. The quick tang from the pickles and mustard was inviting. Then the gooey cheese and barely crisp ham adopted. It was the proper chew and tasted prefer it was served up at a diner.

This was a really profitable air-fryer sandwich for my part. The addition of the pickles and mustard positively elevated it to develop into a dish I would be glad to make for my family and friends.

I tried a rendition of Elvis Presley’s favourite fried peanut butter-and-banana sandwich.

Flat lay of sliced bread, a jar of Jif peanut butter, a rip banana, and a stick of butter.

This sandwich required just a few easy components, together with peanut butter and banana.Victoria Montalti/Insider

After I was desirous about the very best basic, comfort-food sandwiches, Elvis Presley‘s favourite meals didn’t instantly come to thoughts. However when it did, its easy components appeared excellent for this problem. Presley’s favourite meals was mentioned to be a fried peanut butter, banana, and bacon sandwich. This distinctive sandwich (even when recipes do not embody the bacon) is commonly referred to as “The Elvis.”

Sans bacon, it is easy, it is candy, and it is vegan, so I figured I would strive it out. I adopted the Meals Community’s tremendous simple recipe after which added my very own twist of placing it within the air fryer. I used white bread, butter, Jif Creamy Peanut Butter, and a ripe banana.

I buttered one aspect of my slices of bread earlier than flipping them and spreading peanut butter on. I additionally lower the banana into slices and layered them on one piece of bread. Then I merely joined each items of bread collectively and caught a toothpick in.

This easy sandwich makes peanut butter and banana the celebs of the dish.

Side by side of two pieces of bread with peanut butter and sliced banana on it next to the half-cooked sandwich in the air fryer.

After assembling the straightforward components, the peanut butter began to leak out within the air fryer.Victoria Montalti/Insider

Since this sandwich required the bread to crisp greater than it required the peanut butter to soften, I made a decision on cooking it at 300 levels. After a three-minute preheat, I cooked the sandwich for 3 minutes earlier than flipping it over for 3 extra.

After the primary three minutes, the bread seemed slightly damp from the butter. Flipping it included the problem of not getting the peanut butter to seep out in all places. After the following three-minute prepare dinner, my sandwich wasn’t trying so good.

It become an nearly gray coloration, with the peanut butter seeping into the bread and making a monochromatic mess. The bread was additionally not crisping properly due to all of the moisture. I let it relaxation for a few minutes earlier than reducing into it. Once more, this was not visually interesting and I used to be skeptical in regards to the taste.

The peanut butter-and-banana sandwich was monochromatic and never crisp sufficient.

Side by side of the grey-brown sandwich with peanut butter leaking out of it.

The peanut butter seeped into the bread, making it much less crispy. Total, it had a cheesy consistency.Victoria Montalti/Insider

To me, this was not a win. The banana took on an odd consistency and the mixture with the peanut butter made it actually cheesy, sticking to my tooth. The bread was additionally not as crisp because the grilled cheese or ham and cheese, making it lower than passable for my part.

Whereas in idea this seemed like a enjoyable and delicious sandwich, it did not fare properly within the air fryer. I do not assume I shall be consuming this comfort-food sandwich, air-fryer type, once more.

In my view, the eight-cheese grilled cheese and elevated ham-and-cheese sandwiches are price making an attempt and making again and again.

Side by side of the grilled cheese and ham and cheese sandwiches.

The grilled cheese and ham-and-cheese sandwiches have been the tastiest and crispiest.Victoria Montalti/Insider

Total, I feel my air-fried grilled cheese and ham-and-cheese sandwiches have been the tastiest, crispiest, and introduced me probably the most consolation. They really made me so glad and the ham and cheese made me really feel like a chef.

I would not go so far as to say that it’s best to by no means try to make a BLT or a peanut butter-and-banana sandwich within the air fryer. Nevertheless, I do assume you might be higher toasting the bread of a BLT and frying Elvis’ sandwich in a pan as an alternative.

Learn the unique article on Insider